People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Stopped in for a quick slice, decided to get a Margarita pie instead. One of the best Brick oven pies we've had. A must to try! ”
“ I have stopped here to get the pizza to go several times and I have never been disappointed! The pizza is great and so is the calzone. That brick oven taste is delicious. I ask for the pizza a little well done. I've had the Sicilian and regular. Both are good. ”
“ The chicken parmigiana dinner here is delicious. Cooked crisp but not dry and served with pasta and sauce. Dinner comes with soup or salad and bread. Always delicious food. Sometimes while busy it takes a little bit but it is worth it. Entire staff is delightful from the pizza guys to the hostess to the amazing serving staff. Even the delivery drivers are friendly and fast. Food here is always amazing from pizza, chicken tenders and boardwalk fries are yummy. This has become the go to. Especially when having family or friends over or ti go out. You will be satisfied and full. Great job. ”
“ Local pizza spot that just does it right. We took a chance since it was the last pizza spot around us we haven’t tried since moving into the area not too long ago, and it was definitely worth the wait. Taste is great, crunch is great, and it was affordable. Nice family running the spot, too. Looking to make this our usual pizza spot. ”
“ Best Pizza (real brick oven) in the area, a hidden gem. All pasta dishes also a bargain, never had a bad dish. Salads great too, big menu. Too bad they don't have a sign on the highway but definitely recommend. It blows my mind that the place on the corner 300yrds away (CRAP cardboard Pizza) has better reviews just because they are on the highway & have more traffic, sad. No, they don't have white tablecloths, but if you want AMAZING pizza (& never had a bad entre), this is THE place. ”
“ I got a cheesesteak from there and while I don’t even like cheese that much, this was genuinely the most delicious sandwich I’ve ever had. It has a great cheese-pull fit anyone that watches a lot of tik toks like I do. I’m definitely coming back, especially to try the pizzas they have displayed (they look so good). The place is so spacious and beautiful on the inside too. I loved how it was decorated, clean, and the staff was so kind. ”
Menu
Marsala
US$19.95Wood-Fired German (Large)
US$22.95Wood-Fired Alla Vodka (Large)
US$22.95Wood-Fired Quattro Formaggi (Large)
US$18.95Wood-Fired Pizza Bianca (Personal Plain)
US$14.95
About
Pizza Lovers Brick Oven Pizza & Cafe
Welcome to Pizza Lovers Brick Oven Pizza & Cafe, a hidden gem nestled in Washington Township, NJ. Located conveniently at 459 NJ-31, this remarkable eatery offers not just delicious food but a warm and friendly atmosphere to enjoy it in. With the phone number +1 908-574-2261, you can easily reach out for takeout or reserve a table for a delightful dining experience.
One of the standout features of Pizza Lovers is their dedication to quality. Customers rave about the brick oven pizzas, which are made with the freshest ingredients and a time-honored technique that brings out the best in every bite. Nancy's enthusiastic endorsement of the Margarita pie is a testament to the exceptional flavors they create—truly some of the best brick oven pies around.
But it’s not just about the pizza. Todd Osmun's review highlights the delicious chicken parmigiana dinner, praised for its perfect crispness, generous portion of pasta, and delightful sauce. Accompanied by soup or salad and bread, it truly embodies comfort food at its finest. Moreover, the restaurant’s staff consistently earns accolades for their friendly and efficient service, ensuring that every visit is memorable.
The menu also boasts a variety of options, from savory cheesesteaks that have enthralled customers like Melissa Carvalho—highlighting a perfect cheese-pull fit for social media fans—to delectable calzones and impressive pasta dishes that maintain full value without compromising on taste. SuperSurfer Surfer emphasizes how every dish is a bargain, further enhancing the dining experience.
The interior of Pizza Lovers is just as inviting as the food itself. Spacious and beautifully decorated, it provides the perfect backdrop for a family gathering or a casual night out with friends. With a reputation built on amazing food and an unbeatable atmosphere, Pizza Lovers Brick Oven Pizza & Cafe has become a local favorite and a go-to spot for satisfying your cravings.
Whether you're dropping in for a quick slice or planning a larger meal with loved ones, Pizza Lovers is sure to impress with their exceptional offerings and service. There’s no doubt this place is a true culinary delight in the heart of New Jersey.
Book a table